Eduard 1/48 Albatros D.II (L.V.G)
|
|
Albatros D.II (L.V.G) Eduard provides a detailed and accurate model
of this early German fighter, and it should fall together out of the box
without undue trauma to the builder. In fact, most anything the modeler
chooses to add to the Profipack version can be construed as 'gilding the
lily'. So, if you want an enjoyable two-week build, buy the kit and construct
it out of the box; you need read no further. However, if you feel the
need to correct every inaccuracy, however niggling, and add every detail,
however insignificant, grab the gold leaf and let's head to the garden!
If
you're still with me, you already know how to build a rigged biplane.
Accordingly, I do not propose to present a reprise of the experience;
rather, I would like to focus in on specific areas of the project that
presented either challenges or opportunities. These I will describe in
some detail in the hopes that they will be of help or interest. I will
explain the object of an improvement, my selected approach, and whether
or not it was successful. I will confess from the outset that I spent
way more time on this project than I should have needed (236 hours!),
and that there is much about it that is a disappointment to me; some builds
seem to go this way.
Kit Corrections
First off, the kit itself, fine as it is, can use a few corrections
in the interest of more complete accuracy, though it scales very well
to the latest Ian Stair plans. I consulted 13 sets of measurements and
8 different general arrangement drawings, with predictable variations.
These corrections I deemed crucial:
The wheels are badly undersized, a fact widely commented upon. Left
uncorrected, the plane will not sit properly and always look vaguely 'wrong'.
I used Cooper Detail resin replacements, though many options are available.
There
was no aileron control mechanism in the top wing, a distinctive feature
that is very noticeable. This is a straightforward correction, but to
accomplish it the aileron must be completely removed, a slot cut into
the main wing, a control arm added, and the aileron replaced. Then the
hardware and aileron hinge details can be restored with slivers of plastic.
This correction has the additional benefit of enabling the modeler to
offset and so animate the control surfaces. Bitter experience has convinced
me that whenever an aileron must be completely removed, it should be pinned
and epoxied back into place; if one tries to get by with CA glues, he
is forever knocking this component back off. Or is it just me?
The
engine (like most renditions of the Mercedes D.III that I have encountered)
is too small, and sits too low in the fuselage. Like the wheels, this
is a correction that I deemed crucial to replicate the look of the original
plane. I pilfered an engine from Eduard's original release of the Albatros
D.V, a metal version that is closer to the correct overall length of the
prototype. Alternatives would include cutting off and replacing the cylinders
of the kit engine, and raising its location within the fuselage by shimming
up the engine bearer assembly.
On the original machine, the spinner is slightly smaller than the diameter
formed by the nose panels, a feature which promoted engine cooling. I
could not decide in studying the plans and pictures whether the correct
solution to this was diminishing the diameter of the spinner, or beefing
up the contours of the nose; I suspected the latter. But the former was
infinitely easier, and so I chucked the spinner onto a lathe and sanded
it slightly smaller to recreate the prototype's gap.
The roots of the lower wings have been cut back slightly, no doubt
to make assembly a little easier. I restored the missing area with slivers
of plastic, though this is hardly worth the bother.
The fuselage panel lines do not conform to the latest drawings, and
I filled them all. Rather than restore these, I elected to depict them
by varying the paint of the 'wood' panels, a technique that worked fine.
The
wings and tail surfaces are finely molded and accurately contoured, but
they lack any representation of the tapes that should cover the ribs.
This omission needs to be corrected, in my opinion, though one could also
say that this is merely a detail. My favorite method of 'taping' the rib
stations is to slice thin strips of decal film and apply these before
painting. As seen through the topcoats of color, this offers very subtle
and believable appearance; mighty boring to do, though. I am less pleased
with the tapes I created for the undersides, which are drawn on with various
markers and pencils. While easy and quick to accomplish, the lack of any
dimensional variation 'feels' wrong to me.
Cockpit Details
The
cockpit is sufficiently busy to pass muster, but it really could benefit
from a compass, a map case, and a fuel contents gauge, all items that
can be considered as standard on the D.II. Also standard and deserving
inclusion is the control column-mounted throttle assembly. Furthermore,
instruments in this scale deserve improvement over the usual kit-supplied
items. I'll discuss my approach to these in my treatment of the anemometer.
If you really want everything in the cockpit, then better add these as
well:
New fuel selector switch plates from black and silver decal layers.
Create these circles with a miniature punch set and apply in two stages,
centering the slightly smaller black over the larger silver; carefully
scratch enough of the black away to reveal a 'word' or two of the underlying
silver. As long as you are cutting out decals, may as well add the compass
correction card.
Emergency throttle bail by forming a tiny loop at the end of a long,
thin wire.
Access
door and hinge details on the ammunition boxes.
Metal fittings and other details to the rudder bars, including the
control run pulleys and their wires.
A false floor to hide the fuselage seam aft of the control column assembly.
Additional control column details include enhancing the triggers, providing
the Bowden cables for guns and throttle, and the mounting hardware and
control runs for the ailerons and elevators.
Mounting hardware for the seat, its adjustment mechanism, and the attachment
points for the pilot's harness. Note that the bulkhead behind the seat
was not a solid sheet of wood or ply, but ought to have the center section
in fabric.
A
better handle for the starting magneto on the port wall, and the retaining
chain for the ignition magneto switch key. The spark control assembly
can do with some work, too; I think Eduard believes this is the throttle.
All pumps, instruments, and controls need hoses, wires, or actuators,
which can usually best be provided with fine solder, wire, or plastic.
Don't forget the fuel drain and other petrol connections peeping from
behind the fuel selector panel.
Finally, there are a couple of wooden components missing, including
the small triangular brace beneath the fuel selector panel and a slat
on each side of the seat. These last may have been modifications to help
a heavily-bundled pilot heave himself out of the plane.
Engine Details
Once the dimensional anomalies have been sorted out, the modeler can
address improvements, and it is immediately evident that nothing need
be done below the level of the carburetor, as anything accomplished here
will be invisible upon assembly. I chose to supply wire connections to
the sparkplugs, though only the front couple are really visible. I added
valve springs - fine wire wrapped around a suitable mandrel, and improved
the rocker arm covers - slabs of .020 plastic with bolt details. The water
connections on the front of the engine are very evident, and I used brass
wire, fitted into holes drilled in the cylinders. I also used brass to
create the air pump, mounted above the aft cylinders on this particular
160 horsepower engine. Increasingly, I am using prototypical materials
for unpainted metal parts, and have a suitable variety of rods, tubes,
sheets, and bars in brass, copper, and aluminum available to fabricate
these fittings. In the case of the air pump, for instance, it is a very
simple matter to insert telescoping brass tubes into each other, and use
wire for the smallest top diameter and drain assemblies; this approach
eliminates the need for a lathe to turn these items.
I chose to 'wrap' the intake manifold pipes; the Germans used asbestos
tape, and I used thinned body putty painted on the plastic parts. I also
added the not-uncommon numerals to the front of the engine. Finally, I
beefed-up the rather skimpy exhaust pipe by replacing the bell opening
with a suitably-crimped section of plastic tube, and used plastic shims
and body putty to build the pipes to the proper diameters.
Addressing the gun and fuel tank bays aft of the engine is a waste
of time, as these areas are invisible beneath the top wing. Additional
work done to the rear of the engine, including the compression release
handle, synchronizer fittings and cables are also lost to view.
Wood Fuselage
I spent a fair amount of time trying to determine the proper depth
of tone of the plywood fuselage. Conventional wisdom dictates that Albatros
models prior to the D.III were often stained dark; and so they often appear
in period photos. More recently, Dan San Abbott has postulated that these
seemingly dark fuselages are in fact blond, and that orthochromatic film
has rendered this yellowish color much darker than it appeared in nature.
Opinions differ, but I was eventually persuaded that blond was more likely.
So why is the fuselage so dark? Another mistake! Here are the sad facts
of the affair:
I
create the 'wood' by spraying a very light tan over the appropriate areas.
I follow this by producing grain, using a variety of techniques. By smearing
some dark oils across a panel, the underlying tan is stained in a random
pattern. From this pattern, I emphasize the grain using well-thinned oils
applied with a fine brush; besides a dark color, I also use white and
line the undulating lines in bold contrasts. I take care to limit the
graining to a single panel at a time by masking off adjacent areas. Once
the oils have dried, I apply an overspray using Tamiya clear acryllics;
yellow, orange, and green in various combinations can yield a variety
of shades. I mixed a lovely brown and sprayed right past blond and found
myself with a fuselage much darker than I had envisioned. If I had a lighter
touch, I would not now be advocating darker stain as the 'correct' finish
for the Albatros D.II!
The
tinted clear coats build up to a pretty thick coat, even with restraint.
On top of these, I spray multiple coats of Future (Kleer to you Brits)
to provide further depth of finish and a basis for decals. A finish of
10 to 15 coats is too thick to apply over molded details and expect them
to retain any crispness. Another danger is that the thick finish can craze,
or worse, chip off. Crazing can be lightly sanded out without disturbing
the color, but when an area chips off, it will leave a crater down to
the bare plastic that must be sanded extensively. Both of these misadventures
befell me, more than once. The moral is to lightly sand the plastic to
create 'tooth' before starting to paint at all, and to wash the bare plastic
thoroughly to eliminate any contaminates that might affect the paint's
grip. Finally, allow plenty of time between coats to allow each to dry.
I
should address the propeller at this point, an item I usually carve from
veneers (it isn't hard, really!) Since I viewed this project as an exercise
in painting wood, I opted to use the kit-supplied Axial and tried to simulate
the rich contrasts in the same fashion as the rest of the wood. It is
a sad irony that, after years of concocting non-Axial propeller logos,
I should be presented a subject that clearly calls for this ubiquitous
decal at the very time I received Americal Gryphon's spectacular sheet
of German propeller transfers.
Fuselage Details
The radiators need drains, and there are a couple of round access doors
missing. The undercarriage assembly and tail skid both need the bungee
cords, and the undercarriage struts are improved by the addition of some
of the hardware. Metal panels require fasteners, which I supplied with
tiny slices of stretched sprue. I chose to replace the pilot's mounting
step kick plate with a version that features a grid pattern; I embossed
the back of aluminum foil to create this effect.
I
elected to use the Eduard-provided masks to paint some of the doors and
louvers of the fuselage once it had been rendered in the 'wood' tones,
and in this I believe I made a major mistake. Because my technique to
simulate the plywood necessarily involves multiple coats of paint, the
crispness of Eduard's molded details were lost; worse, any mistake in
applying the mask creates a glaring anomaly, and I created several.
In future, I will remove all such details with a knife and sandpaper,
create the wood surface, and reapply the prepainted details; an approach
I followed for most of the other fuselage-mounted details, but, alas,
not all. A fine adhesive for adding prepainted details to a painted surface
is 5-minute epoxy. A dot of this will provide more than enough holding
power, and any smears can be washed away with a brushful of alcohol without
effecting the paint. It was with this adhesive that the majority of fuselage
details were attached - it is much less prone to problems than cyanoacrylic.
Personal Markings
My
chosen subject was Leutnant Robert Dyke's aircraft from Jasta 16b. This
was an LVG-built machine in the serial range 1024/16 to 1061/16, operational
early in 1917 from Ensisheim north of Mulhouse . It is well documented
with photographs showing it from every angle, and Greg Van Wyngarden kindly
supplied very clear shots of the distinctive Bavarian personal markings
on the fuselage sides. These days, some basic software on the personal
computer, coupled with an ALPS or Laser printer, can create the markings
in fairly short order. But if you like to do things the hard way, here's
how I did it with eight different pieces of various decals:
I cut appropriately sized lozenges from black and white decal stock.
The black diamond is fractionally larger than the white to provide the
black border when the white decal is overlaid upon the black. I added
a second white diamond to ensure a bright white shade.
Delving into the decal stash, I came up with a number of suitably sized
Austrian crests as used on the tails of KuK naval planes. I carefully
cut the red/white/red bars from within the shield, and removed the crowns
for later use.
A
lengthy browse through the decals at the local hobby shop produced a strip
of what we would call Bavarian Wappenschild, though I suspect the Oregon
Air National Guard calls it something else; the decals were meant for
1/72 scale jets. This bit of serendipity may strain credulity, but I was
prepared to cut my own tiny blue diamonds and apply them. As it was, all
was not perfect as the diamonds were only three wide and so multiple tiny
slivers were required.
Placing the first of two gold shields enabled me to locate the area
in which I needed to assemble the Wappenschild; once the field of diamonds
was laid down, the second shield hid the ragged edges.
I modified the Austrian crown to more closely resemble the one on the
Bavarian arms with a few strokes of gold paint, and placed it to finish
Dycke's marking.
I realize that no one is likely to want to repeat this exercise, but
it is worth considering as a means of producing an unusual subject. By
regarding a particular marking as an assembly of simpler elements, the
field of possibilities widens considerably, and the vast numbers of decals
available for other areas of interest is a potential resource for the
World War One enthusiast.
Struts
I
was determined to improve upon the usual presentation of interplane struts,
and the very fine illustrations from Flight showed precisely how these
components were attached on the original. I began by shortening the kit
struts by a couple of millimeters and inserted wire pins into both ends.
I erred here, being too cautious, and would have been well advised to
remove twice as much plastic and use longer pins. I glued small plastic
polygons on the wings at the strut locations, and drilled a deeper mounting
hole to accept the pins. After the top wing had been erected in the assembly
process, I added the 'ears' to the strut plates, and simulated the through-bolt
by gluing plastic bolt heads on both sides.
Did
it work? Well, yes, but I should have used thin brass, and bent the ears
from the mounting brackets instead of relying on plastic additions. A
more ambitious approach would have been to bore through the strut pin
and actually use a tiny metal 'bolt', which would have contributed to
the finesse of the finished product as well as simulate exactly the original
mount.
I found some LVG decals on one of Americal/Gryphon's many sheets (everyone
should stock a large variety of these, as there is always some delightful
treasure to be found on every one), and dressed up the strut itself.
Rigging
I
am a confirmed monofilament user, these days employing DaiRiki fishing
line of .003 and .005 diameters and pre-coloring it with a permanent marker.
I used to drill holes completely through wing surfaces and secure the
lines with knots and globs of CA glue. But I have determined that there
is ample strength in the glue itself, and now only drill holes completely
through the lower wing; the upper wing is partially drilled from the underside,
and the thread embedded in glue. This saves a lot of time in repairing
topside holes, and limits the cleanup to the underside of the lower wing,
where any flaws in the finish are far less noticeable.
I am, however, seeking improvements in turnbuckles, and have tried
a number of approaches without hitting upon a method that I will use to
the exclusion of all others. Photoetched parts, while promising, have
hitherto presented too much additional work and their two-dimensional
nature leaves me cold. On this model, I used pairs of white glue spots,
painted on the rigging line about 2 millimeters apart. The slight bulges
so created were emphasized with a spot of dark paint, and the intervening
space painted brass to simulate a turnbuckle of that material. This works
okay for an early machine like the D.II, as the different colors help
create an impression that looks more complicated than it really is. The
results would be less effective on a model whose turnbuckles would not
be quite so colorful - like late war RAF aircraft. The search goes on.
Anemometer
The
attached sketch illustrates the rather elaborate lengths to which I went
to recreate this wing-mounted instrument. While a lathe and drill press
make the creation of a brass version easier, these same steps can be accomplished
using plastic and a pin vice drill to make the body; the PE bits provide
the intricate details. As with the decals, a willingness to look beyond
a part's original purpose will yield dividends. In this case, a photoetched
1/72 control wheel and spoked main wheel were pressed into service after
the rims were removed. I removed all but four of the main wheel's spokes,
and bent these into the protective cage that surrounds the instrument's
spinning cups. The control wheel's arms were twisted 90 degrees to become
the mounts for the cups. The hole in each part's central hub makes construction
easy; the parts stack up on the mounting rod, and are secured with the
merest touch of CA glue. I used a punch to create tiny brass disks, and
then pressed them into a cup shape by placing them on a mat and bearing
down with a rounded stylus.
In
1/48, the dial face of an instrument needs to be readable to create any
illusion of reality. I happen to care that the gauge face also be accurate,
but this is less important than its clarity. Fortunately, a number of
companies cater to this need, Eduard and Copper State offering accurate
instrument faces, and Reheat, Waldron, and a host of car model makers
offering alternatives not specific to World War One. Too, it is a relatively
simple matter to draw an accurate face in larger scale, and reduce this
on a copier to the size needed.
Once the face is obtained, it needs to be attached to a suitably sized
instrument case. I take utmost care to make sure the adhesive in this
step does not distort the clarity, a danger when one is using a clear
film face as provided by Copper State. I usually accomplish this by placing
tiny dots of a clear varnish around the very edges of the dial face where
the glue will be ultimately hidden by the bezel. 'Glass' in the form of
clear acetate or plastic is attached next, with the same care to ensure
nothing gets on the face. Finally, one or more PE bezels surmount the
glass. I select the bezel based on its accurate configuration, of course,
but also on its color; these come in natural brass or aluminum, or dark
gray. Again, different manufacturers make this easy, Fotocut, Part, and
Reheat providing brass, Copper State and the model car industry aluminum,
and Eduard a darkened version. And, it is also possible to chemically
darken brass ñ I want to avoid obscuring any details with paint.
Once this sandwich of parts is united, the raw edges these different
layers can be smoothed and painted in the body color of the instrument.
Finally, a suitable wire is attached if applicable. As with most detail
creation, the possession of a miniature punch set to create tiny disks
of different materials is absolutely vital.
Besides the anemometer, the fuel pressure and contents gauges, tachometer,
and compass were treated in this fashion.
Conclusion
For
what was to be an easy and relaxing diversion from more complicated projects,
I managed to spend a lot of effort. And, since I was trying to perfect
my technique for painting wood, I felt I botched the job, or at least
missed my aiming point. Still, hope springs eternal!
References:
-
Windsock Datafile (Albatros D.II) and Datafile Special of Albatros
Fighters
-
Ian Stairs' Albatros Fighters of WWI
-
Squadron/Signal's Albatros Fighters in Action
-
Rudolf Hofling's Albatros D.II
-
Robert Mikesh and the Smithsonians's Albatros D.Va
-
Osprey's Albatros Aces of WWI
Periodicals:
-
Cross and Cockade Great Britain/International 5/3 and 26/3
-
World War One Aeroplane 103, 112, 123, 150
-
Over the Front 5/1, 7/4 15/2
Editor's Note: This article originally ran in Windsock 19/4. Thanks
to Ray Rimell and Albatros
Productions Ltd. for allowing its use here - RNP
|
|